Reviewers: ππππβ»οΈ β’ Gabriele Ciminelli (Asia School of Business) | πππβ»οΈβ»οΈ
To read the original manuscript, click the link above.
Summary of Reviews: Reviewers find that this paper raises important questions about overstating the importance of government-mandated non-pharmaceutical interventions, but that it is undermined by unclear inclusion criteria and overly-broad conclusions that are not all supported by the evidence.
Reviewer 1 | ππππβ»οΈ
Reviewer 2 (Gabriele Ciminelli) | πππ β»οΈβ»οΈ
RR:C19 Strength of Evidence Scale Key π β»οΈβ»οΈβ»οΈβ»οΈ = Misleading ππ β»οΈβ»οΈβ»οΈ = Not Informative πππ β»οΈβ»οΈ = Potentially Informative ππππβ»οΈ = Reliable πππππ = Strong |
To read the reviews, click the links below.